A Deadly Education

Library Liberty Zed reviewed A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik (The Scholomance, #1)

It is that good.

5 stars

Content warning Spoiler

The initial exposition of the world may stumble a bit in its execution, yet this is forgivable given the captivating depth of the setting. But this is also due to the fact that the world is uniquely interesting. Regrettably, the world-building occasionally interrupts exciting story points, requiring readers to endure a page or two of the main character's first-person explanation before the actual plot continues. he actual basic story is typical fantasy with a fated superpower and a heroine story. Much has already been said and written about the book and I concur: Recommended. However, I have to add. It ends on a typical newer TV Show trope: The cliffhanger, which is kinda resolved in minutes...and is therefore annoying. For TV Shows I usullay stop in the middle of an episode to avoid this kind of absurd cliffhanger. It's the first time I come across it in a book.

Matt K reviewed A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik (The Scholomance, #1)

A tasty introduction

5 stars

Cons: It's not really a standalone. You'll want to know more and the cliffhanger at the end is primo.

Pros: Everything else. Characters are great and evolve, world seems consistent, the reasons magic doesn't solve everything feel right, the

El (Short for Galadriel, like, you know, "All shall love me and despair!”) is an outcast and a hard worker. Her mom is a kind hippy wizard who sees her differently than the rest of the world, which is to say her mom loves her and doesn't think she is a force of darkness destined to be an evil supervillain. She works hard to do things ONLY in the good ways so she never sets a foot on the path of darkness, no matter how many people she desires to invert over an ant-pile in the course of a day.

We meet El inside the Scholomance, a superdark high school for …

Cons: It's not really a standalone. You'll want to know more and the cliffhanger at the end is primo.

Pros: Everything else. Characters are great and evolve, world seems consistent, the reasons magic doesn't solve everything feel right, the

El (Short for Galadriel, like, you know, "All shall love me and despair!”) is an outcast and a hard worker. Her mom is a kind hippy wizard who sees her differently than the rest of the world, which is to say her mom loves her and doesn't think she is a force of darkness destined to be an evil supervillain. She works hard to do things ONLY in the good ways so she never sets a foot on the path of darkness, no matter how many people she desires to invert over an ant-pile in the course of a day.

We meet El inside the Scholomance, a superdark high school for teen wizards. In this world, magical monsters LOVE the taste of young wizards and consume them like junk food. The Scholomance was founded to give young wizards a better shot at growing up by teaching them in a place where only 60% of them would die instead of the 80% that were munched in the outside.

Graduation day in this school is a horrific race to escape the school while a sea of monsters scoop up as many kids as they can.

In this brutal world everyone is in constant danger and looking for an edge for survival. It's set up as a zero sum game - everyone knows that most of the people around them in freshman year will be dead before they leave. You are looking for any advantage possible to keep you in the fraction of kids that make it out. The class inequalities outside the walls are of course reflected inside and we get to learn about how it all works through El's eyes as she struggles to not alienate the powerful despite her instincts - if she can be in with the powerful kids, she stands a chance of making it out the doors. Of course the powerful exploit their advantages as well and demand anything that will help tip their odds.

But every single chance she's given she finds herself turning away from. Even when she attracts the attention of Orion Lake, the nearly invulnerable wizard in her class with an talent for slaying monsters far beyond his years. Yes, yes, yes of course, but the journey is a good one.

The end is a triumph as characters discover hidden talents, strengths, connections and the power of working WITH each other instead of trying to get an advantage over each other. And the final sentence sets you up for a hell of a ride in the next book.

Alex Cabe reviewed A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik

Excellent Trilogy Starter

No rating

I put a lot of weight on the main character, and El is relatable in a prickly, keep-your-distance kind of way. Thoroughly enjoyable to read.

The magic system was unique and very well thought out. The social commentary was obvious, but enjoyable. I'm interested to see if they expand the worldbuilding beyond the school in the later books.

I desperately want a My Immortal version of this, and it's also sort of like this is a somehow good version of My Immortal.

Drawbacks: El does tend to infodump. It's also painfully obvious that this is the first part of a trilogy rather than a complete story. Not sure I've ever read a book where that was so obvious.

Julie R reviewed A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik (The Scholomance, #1)

entertaining and unique

4 stars

Loved the premise here, even if at times I questioned some of the internal logic of the magic laws at work. I was a little put off at the start by the narrative tone, but I eventually found a rhythm and it stopped bothering me. I'm looking forward to reading the rest of the series.

Blackberry Jim reviewed A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik (The Scholomance, #1)

A Deadly Education

5 stars

Aw, this was a lot of fun. I enjoy the author’s other work and I’m glad that I enjoy this one too - and have a series to look forward to! On my library audiobook app it’s titled ‘A Deadly Education: TikTok made me read it’ which is very funny to me, I didn’t know it got big on tiktok. It makes sense though, it’s good YA that has (imo) well-executed themes of privilege & how it can be ignored by those who benefit from it, it’s got an undeniably dark academia-compatible setting, and it’s got… like…. a ratfic (as in fiction coming out of the rationalist community, like uhhh HPMOR) vibe, if ratfic identified itself more often as a viewpoint particularly attractive to teenagers as a kind of bad way of dealing with a specific set of probably temporary dissatisfactions than the ratfic I’ve read has. (That is pretty …

Aw, this was a lot of fun. I enjoy the author’s other work and I’m glad that I enjoy this one too - and have a series to look forward to! On my library audiobook app it’s titled ‘A Deadly Education: TikTok made me read it’ which is very funny to me, I didn’t know it got big on tiktok. It makes sense though, it’s good YA that has (imo) well-executed themes of privilege & how it can be ignored by those who benefit from it, it’s got an undeniably dark academia-compatible setting, and it’s got… like…. a ratfic (as in fiction coming out of the rationalist community, like uhhh HPMOR) vibe, if ratfic identified itself more often as a viewpoint particularly attractive to teenagers as a kind of bad way of dealing with a specific set of probably temporary dissatisfactions than the ratfic I’ve read has. (That is pretty scathing, which may not be merited. Maybe I have just read the worse bits of rationalism.) It did a much better job of grounding the protagonist’s actions in her believable personality as well - honestly that was something I really enjoyed throughout this book.

There’s worldbuilding stuff I could try and nitpick but it didn’t impact my enjoyment of a generally very fun and expansive-feeling world. I get the sense that a lot of very interesting and very different stories could take place in a thousand different places in this world and not diminish each other, which is nice.

Rating 5/5 - just what I want from YA :3

chadkoh reviewed A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik (The Scholomance, #1)

Review of 'A Deadly Education' on 'Goodreads'

5 stars

Anissa Dadia does an excellent job as narrator keeping you interested in a book that starts out featuring an angsty teenage dark mage who is in a terrible place by force. Naomi Novik deserves credit for setting up such a difficult task as an author. But as things progress, and the book wins the reader over, we get to see Novik’s ability to subtly include allegory on a number of real world social ills. That and some very nice language work… plus a very good ending making me get the second volume right away. 4.5 stars rounded up!

ranjit@bookwyrm.social reviewed A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik (The Scholomance, #1)

Fun all the way through

4 stars

A lot of reviewers complained reasonably that the worldbuilding is pretty unbelievable at times, but I was having too much fun to notice.

I loved the big gimmick underlying the whole book: the protagonist has the talents and affinities to be the most powerful and destructive necromancer of her generation - there’s even prophecies about her! - but she was raised by pacifist hippies and works incredibly hard not to accidentally incinerate or mind-control her classmates, building power not by sacrificing animals but through push-ups and crochet.